Entries Tagged 'Quests/RSS Reader' ↓

RSS Reader shootout

Well, the summer’s here and it’s time for the silly season to start - sorting out software to use which I really should have made a decision about earlier.

Investigating PHP IDEs was the first task, now it’s RSS Readers. I’ve been using Opera 8’s built-in reader, but since “going back to Firefox”:http://peter.mapledesign.co.uk/weblog/archives/opera_lover_concedes_defeat.html it’s been getting annoying to fire up this browser just to read my feeds (another footprint in my memory)

So… stand-alone program time. Rule 1 is that the program must be free. So I’ve been testing:

# “RSSBandit”:http://www.rssbandit.org 1.3.0.29
# “GreatNews”:http://www.curiostudio.com 1.0 Beta (Build 315)
# “Sauce Reader”:http://www.synop.com/Products/SauceReader/ 2.0.1(Beta)

“RSSBandit”:http://www.rssbandit.orgis definitely free; I am unsure about GreatNews, it’s still in beta form and no mention of a price at present.

Rule 2 is that it has to fit in with my use of a RSS reader: I use it as a way to keep and archive articles of interest. Any I don’t want (lots) I delete, so this deleting process needs to be as easy as possible. This means using and to select items.

I like the newspaper display of items, but if this is present and I’m deleting items, I want the display to update, not change to a single-item display.

A lot of problems come about because RSS readers treat items as if they were email, a metaphor I can never understand. A different approach is clearly needed IMO.

h3. Day 1.

“GreatNews”:http://www.curiostudio.comhas the attraction of synching with “Bloglines”:http://www.bloglines.com which allows you to read the RSS feeds whether on the move or at your computer. I love this feature, although I’ve never been ecstatic about the Bloglines interface. Now honestly, why I like it so much I’m not sure as I’ve usually got my laptop with me, but there you go… I guess the biggest advantage is that my blogroll on this website is always up-to-date.

and don’t select multiple items in GreatNews, so you have to delete items

In a way it’s an unfair comparison as “GreatNews”:http://www.curiostudio.comis still in beta before the release of the first version, while the other two programs are mature. However life isn’t fair and I’m testing now ;-)
RSSBandit, like all the other programs, has a cool interface. I’ve done most of my reading in it so far, mainly because I didn’t get round to installing “Sauce Reader”:http://www.synop.com/Products/SauceReader/until later on.

“Sauce Reader”:http://www.synop.com/Products/SauceReader/has a cool “Show in Groups” feature which groups the items by date. It also has an integrated weblog editor (to write a post in) which would be fine if I didn’t care about the HTML produced at the end. The other feature I really liked is the way you can delete items from the newspaper view - hello, anyone else think this is a good idea? This feature alone is putting it strides ahead of the others.

I’ll keep you posted as I progress with using them. If there’s any others you think I should play with, post a comment to this entry and I’ll install them.